top of page

The Most Romantic Cheeses for Valentine’s Day

Madison

Forget cliché chocolates and predictable roses—this Valentine’s Day, say “I love you” with cheese. Rich, indulgent, and undeniably satisfying, cheese is the perfect way to set the mood, whether you’re planning a romantic night in, surprising the cheese lover in your life, or treating yourself (because self-love is important too). From heart-shaped beauties to chocolate-infused creations, these decadent selections are guaranteed to make February 14th extra special.


Heart-Shaped Cheeses: Love at First Sight

Nothing says romance like flowers—especially when they’re edible. This brand-new double cream cow’s milk cheese is dusted with delicate rose petals and lavender, making it as stunning as it is delicious. Its velvety texture and subtle floral notes pair beautifully with a glass of sparkling rosé and honey-drizzled crackers. It’s almost too pretty to eat (but trust us, you’ll want to).

Nettle Meadow Hearts & Roses   Photo By: Nettle Meadow
Nettle Meadow Hearts & Roses Photo By: Nettle Meadow

Triple cream, triple the indulgence. This organic cow’s milk cheese is pure luxury, boasting a buttery texture and a fudgy, melt-in-your-mouth paste. Perfect for a cozy date night—spread it on a crusty baguette, pop open your favorite champagne, and let the romance begin.

Cowgirl Creamery Heart's Desire    Photo By: Murray's Cheese
Cowgirl Creamery Heart's Desire Photo By: Murray's Cheese

Who says cheddar can’t be romantic? This heart-shaped wheel brings bold, tangy flavors with a deep, aged richness that any cheese enthusiast will adore. Add some apple slices, candied nuts, and a dollop of chutney for the perfect balance of sharp and sweet.

Flavored Cheeses: Because Love Should Be Extra

Chocolate and cheese? Yes, please. This ultra-rich, buttery triple cream from New York’s Hudson Valley gets a decadent twist with a layer of dark milk chocolate from famed French chocolatier Pralus. Aged together for two weeks, the flavors meld into a luxurious experience that’s unlike anything you’ve tasted before. Think Morbier, but instead of ash, you get chocolate. (Cue the heart eyes.)


Murray’s Triple Creme de Cocoa    Photo: Murray's Cheese
Murray’s Triple Creme de Cocoa Photo: Murray's Cheese

Can’t decide between cheese or chocolate? You don’t have to. This Wisconsin cheddar-based fudge is creamy, nutty, and just sweet enough to feel indulgent. Pair it with fresh berries and whipped cream for a dessert that combines the best of both worlds.

Inspired by the classic Valentine’s Day pairing of strawberries and champagne, this goat cheese log blends fresh strawberries into a creamy, tangy base. It’s dreamy on a cheese board and even better when paired with a glass of bubbly and a bit of dark chocolate.

Gift Boxes: When You Want It All

Can’t decide? Let the experts handle it. This curated box is filled with handpicked cheeses, charcuterie, and the perfect accompaniments for an effortlessly romantic spread. Just add wine, candles, and good company for a night to remember.

Murray's Valentines Day Collection   Photo: Murray's Cheese
Murray's Valentines Day Collection Photo: Murray's Cheese

If your Valentine loves bold flavors, this cheddar-packed box is the way to go. With varieties like the fiery Wickedly Habanero, creamy 3-Year Cheddar, and intensely sharp Vermont classics, this gift set is made for cheese lovers who like a little excitement.

Cabot Cheddar Gift Box   Photo By: Cabot Cheese
Cabot Cheddar Gift Box Photo By: Cabot Cheese

For the ultimate indulgence, this set brings together three seasonal artisan cheeses, three gourmet chocolates, and two exclusive truffles made with fresh goat cheese and raspberry jam. It’s romance in a box—no effort required.

Cheese Grotto's Cheese and Chocolate Box    Photo: Cheese Grotto
Cheese Grotto's Cheese and Chocolate Box Photo: Cheese Grotto

Because Love (and Cheese) is Meant to Be Shared

Whether you’re planning a fancy spread or a laid-back night with wine and Netflix, these Valentine’s Day cheeses are the ultimate way to say “I love you.” So go ahead, skip the predictable gifts and give your sweetheart something truly unforgettable—because nothing says romance like a bite of pure, creamy perfection.

bottom of page